The Superstition and Science of Eating in the Dark

The idea that eating in the dark brings bad luck is a belief found in various cultures, often rooted in a combination of supernatural warnings and practical concerns from a time before electricity was common. Across several traditions, the answer to whether it's bad luck is "yes," though the reasons differ. These age-old superstitions stand in contrast to the modern culinary trend of "dining in the dark," which reframes the experience as a sensory adventure. While modern research finds no supernatural danger, it does reveal that low light can have measurable effects on our eating habits and health.

Cultural Beliefs Around the World

Different cultures have unique interpretations of why dining in darkness is discouraged. These beliefs often involve supernatural entities, warnings of misfortune, or breaches of social conduct. A Japanese proverb, however, flips the notion, suggesting a dark-eating mishap could be a sign of good fortune.

Region / Culture	Belief	Consequence or Meaning
Malay	Eating in the dark means you are dining with devils.	A practical warning that spills attract pests, with a supernatural layer of evil entities joining the meal.
Nigeria	Dark meals invite ghosts, spirits, or the devil to join you.	It is thought that sharing food with these entities could lead to severe illness or death.
Uganda	Turning the lights off at dinner brings demons.	This can result in haunting and general bad luck.
Nyakyusa (Tanzania)	Eating unseen or alone is a sign of selfishness and greed.	This belief serves to protect communal food norms and social unity.
Turkey	Chewing gum after dark turns it into the flesh of the dead.	While not a full meal, it reflects a fear of consuming something undesirable in the absence of light.
Japan	If you accidentally touch food to your nose while eating in the dark, money is coming.	An exception where a chance event in the dark can be a sign of good fortune.

Historical and Practical Origins of the Superstition

Beyond the supernatural, the superstition is grounded in practical concerns that were especially relevant in pre-electric homes. These real-world risks likely gave rise to frightening tales used to enforce safe behavior.

Safety & Hygiene: In low light, it is difficult to properly inspect food for spoilage, mold, or insects. The risk of choking on bones or other hazards increases, and if someone does choke, others may not be able to see them to offer help. Furthermore, using utensils in the dark could lead to accidental cuts or injuries.
Pest Prevention: Eating in the dark makes food spillage more likely. In older homes, spilled food would attract ants, insects, and other pests, making cleanliness a major concern.
Social Discipline: For some cultures like the Nyakyusa of Tanzania, the prohibition was not about ghosts but about reinforcing social cohesion. Sayings that branded solo, unseen eating as greedy helped protect communal dining norms.
Spiritual Boundaries: The fear of the dark is a common human anxiety rooted in the unknown. Nigerian and Ugandan lore personifies hidden threats by using "spirits" and "demons" as stand-ins for the real dangers that could lurk at night, creating a powerful deterrent.

The Modern Scientific Perspective

Modern science has explored the psychological and physiological effects of eating in the dark, separating fact from folklore. While no ghosts will join your meal, eating without light does influence behavior and biology.

Physiological Effects and Health

Overeating: Research shows that dim lighting can lead diners to underestimate portion sizes and choose richer, less healthy foods, which may explain links between late-night eating and weight gain.
Circadian Rhythms: Animal studies have demonstrated that exposure to low light at night can shift meal timing and drive obesity, even without an increase in calorie consumption. This suggests that light is a key regulator of our metabolic health.

Sensory Perception and Satiety

How we perceive food is a multisensory experience where sight plays a major role. Removing it changes things, though not always as expected.

Taste, Smell, and Texture: Some people report a heightened sense of taste and smell as the brain compensates for the lack of visual input. The texture of food can also become more prominent. However, without visual confirmation, it can be surprisingly difficult to identify specific flavors.
Satiety and Mindfulness: The effect on fullness is debated. For some, darkness promotes mindful eating by removing distractions and encouraging a focus on internal cues of hunger, potentially leading them to eat less. For others, the lack of visual information can be disorienting and interfere with the feeling of satiety.

The Modern Trend: "Dining in the Dark" Restaurants

In stark contrast to traditional superstitions, "dining in the dark" has become a popular culinary experience. These restaurants intentionally create a pitch-black environment to transform the act of eating into a novel adventure.

Heightened Senses: The primary goal is to enhance the other senses—taste, smell, touch, and hearing—allowing for a more profound appreciation of the food's flavors and textures.
Mindful Eating and Social Connection: The experience encourages diners to pay closer attention to their meal. Without visual distractions like phones, proponents suggest that conversations become more engaging and intimate.
Empathy and Awareness: Many "dining in the dark" restaurants employ blind or visually impaired staff, offering sighted guests a brief but powerful glimpse into their world and fostering a greater understanding of blindness.

Conclusion

The belief that eating in the dark is bad luck is deeply rooted in historical and cultural contexts where darkness posed real dangers. Practical concerns about safety, hygiene, and social order were wrapped in supernatural tales of ghosts and devils to create a powerful social custom. Today, while no ghost will appear if you snack with the lights off, a little illumination still serves a purpose. It helps us avoid spills, inspect our food, eat mindfully, and keep our circadian rhythms happy. And for those seeking adventure, the modern trend of dining in the dark turns an ancient fear into a unique exploration of the senses.

Works Cited

10 funny superstitious beliefs every Nigerian has heard. (2021, December 15). Pulse Nigeria.
13 Food and Cooking Superstitions From Around the World. (2024, October 30).
7 Crazy Food Superstitions To Digest. (2023, October 18). Farmers' Almanac.
Chef’s Pencil, “Uganda: Keep the Lights on When You Eat.”
Dining in the dark. (2012, December 16). BPS.
Dining in the Dark: The Sensory Experience of Eating Without Sight. (2020, February 24). Joyful Eating Nutrition.
Edensor & Falconer, “Dans Le Noir?” Cultural Geographies 22 (4).
Five Superstitions From the Zona Maya. (2023, July 31). Na'atik Language & Culture Institute.
Fonken et al., “Light at Night Increases Body Mass…,” PNAS, 2010.
FoodNavigator, July 9 2024 study summary.
Google Arts & Culture. (n.d.). 18 Superstitions from Around the World.
Good Luck- Bad Luck. (n.d.).
IJFMR 6 (6), “Nyakyusa Superstitious Sayings.”
Is Eating In The Dark Bad Luck?. (2022, April 14).
Makansutra, “Asian Food Superstitions.”
Nairaland Forum, December 28 2014 thread.
Nigerian History & Demographics, “Nigerian Superstitions.”
The Dining in the Dark Phenomenon. (n.d.). ResearchGate.
TIME, “Why We Eat So Much at the Movies,” Aug 8 2023.
Wikisource, Sketches of Tokyo Life, Ch. 5.