Home > Is It Bad Luck to Keep Pet Ashes in the House? A Comprehensive Investigation

Is It Bad Luck to Keep Pet Ashes in the House?

So, your beloved furball is now... well, ash. Is it weird or unlucky to keep the urn on your mantelpiece? Let's find out.
Disclaimer: The pictures shown here are meant to visually support the topic. They’re imaginative or representative visuals, not depictions of real situations or individuals.

Losing a pet is rough. Deciding what to do with their ashes can be even weirder. A lot of people wonder if it's bad juju to keep them in the house, so we’ll look at where this idea comes from, what different beliefs say, and what really matters when you're grieving.

A decorative urn containing a pet's ashes sitting on a sunlit mantelpiece next to a framed photo of a dog.

Common Worries and Questions

The "Bad Luck" Belief Today

The idea that keeping pet ashes is bad luck isn't some ancient curse. It's actually a pretty modern worry, cobbled together from different anxieties you see popping up on places like online forums and social media groups. 1

A big fear is that the ashes create "negative energy" in your home, making the vibe heavy and preventing you from moving on from the loss. 3 The thinking goes that a house is for the living, and keeping a reminder of death around throws things out of whack. 5

People also worry they're trapping their pet's spirit, keeping it from crossing the "Rainbow Bridge." 6 What's meant as a loving tribute suddenly feels like you're holding your best friend's soul hostage. This is basically an old fear about unburied humans getting applied to pets. 7

You see these fears in online stories. People don't usually report full-on ghost pet sightings, but they'll talk about feeling sad or uneasy in the house after bringing the ashes home. 8 They then blame the ashes for the "bad luck." This is how modern folklore works, it's built in real-time online as one person's worry gets shared and confirmed by others. 10

Where Did This Fear Come From?

The superstition about pet ashes is new because cremating pets is a recent thing. 11 But the anxieties behind it are old, really old. They come from ancient human taboos about death that we've started applying to our pets as they've become part of the family.

Historically, humans had all sorts of rituals for dealing with their dead, mostly to keep the living separate from the dead. 13 Animals didn't get this treatment. But now that pets are family, they inherit all our emotional baggage about death, including the love, grief, and memorializing, alongside the primal fear of remains and unsettled spirits. 11

You can see this in old fears about the "revenant," or restless dead. People in ancient Greece and medieval Europe would bury bodies with heavy rocks or sickles to stop them from coming back to haunt the living. 16 That deep-seated terror of the "unsettled dead" is the ancestor of today's much milder anxiety about keeping an urn on the shelf.

Illustration of an ancient burial ritual, showing people placing symbolic items in a grave.

This connects to the idea of a final resting place. Many cultures believe a soul needs its remains to be buried or scattered to move on peacefully. 17 Keeping ashes on a mantelpiece can feel like leaving the soul in limbo.

The ancient belief that the physical body is still linked to the soul after death plays a big role here. 19 Egyptians mummified bodies to help the soul in the afterlife, showing how strong this link was thought to be. 20 This all feeds the modern fear that pet ashes can "trap" a spirit. 21

Spiritual and Spooky Beliefs

The anxiety around pet ashes is fueled by a mix of different belief systems, from Feng Shui to ghost stories. A grieving owner might be wrestling with all these ideas at once, making "bad luck" a simple label for a complicated feeling.

Feng Shui and Yin-Yang Energy

A big reason people worry comes from Feng Shui, the Chinese practice of balancing energy. 10 In Feng Shui, your home should be a Yang space, full of active, living energy ( chi ). Objects tied to death are considered intensely Yin , or still and quiet. 23

Key Concept: In Feng Shui, Yang represents active, living energy, while Yin represents still, quiet energy associated with rest and death. The goal is to balance these forces in your home for harmony.

Placing ashes, a powerful Yin object, in a Yang home is thought to create an energy clash that drains the good vibes. 23 This can supposedly make people feel sad, tired, or stuck in their grief. 25

Strict Feng Shui says to return the ashes to the earth or water. 25 But if you want to keep them, some experts suggest ways to balance the energy. Don't put the urn in the bedroom or near the front door, maybe try a den or library instead.

You can also counteract the Yin energy by adding Yang elements nearby, like living plants, sunlight, and happy photos of your pet. 23

A pet's urn placed in a well-lit corner of a room, balanced with a healthy green plant and happy photos.

Ghost Stories: Is Your Pet's Spirit Trapped?

Some paranormal believers think ashes can act as a "spirit anchor" or beacon. 21 The idea is that the remains have a strong energy link to the deceased, which can trap the spirit on earth and keep it from crossing over. 28, 29 This leads to fears of a haunting, with the spirit lingering near its urn. 9

But... this isn't the only ghost-hunter theory! Many other experts and mediums say the spirit leaves the body at death, making the ashes just an empty shell. 6 They argue that spirits are more drawn to the energy of living people than to a jar of dust. 22 In this view, the ashes are just a memorial, and your pet's spirit is long gone and free.

What Major Religions Say

Most major religions don't have rules for pet ashes, but their traditions for human remains heavily influence how people feel. That little voice telling you it's "wrong" to keep ashes at home might just be an echo of these ancient religious norms.

Belief System Stance on Cremation Stance on Keeping Ashes at Home Core Rationale
Catholicism Permitted since 1963, but burial is preferred. 30 Strongly discouraged. 17 Remains must be interred in a sacred place (cemetery, columbarium) to show reverence for the body as a temple of the Holy Spirit and to affirm the belief in the resurrection of the body. Scattering is forbidden. 32
Protestantism Widely accepted; a matter of personal choice. 30 Generally permitted; a matter of personal choice. 30 Most denominations do not have strict guidelines, focusing on honoring the deceased in a way that brings comfort to the family.
Orthodox Christianity Strictly forbidden. 30 Not applicable, as cremation is prohibited. The body must be buried intact as it is considered a sacred vessel that will be resurrected. Cremation is seen as a desecration. 32
Hinduism Mandated (known as antim sanskar ). 30 Strongly discouraged. 17 Cremation is believed to liberate the soul from the physical body. Ashes are traditionally scattered in a sacred river, like the Ganges, to aid the soul's journey toward moksha (liberation). Keeping them at home is thought to hinder this process. 17
Buddhism Preferred and widely practiced. 30 Permitted, often temporarily. 17 Ashes may be kept on a family altar for a period of mourning before being interred or scattered. The focus is on non-attachment to the physical form.
Judaism Traditionally forbidden (Orthodox, Conservative). 30 Not applicable in traditional practice. Jewish law requires the body to be buried intact in the earth. Cremation is seen as a violation of the body, which is considered God's property. Reform Judaism is increasingly accepting of cremation. 30
Islam Strictly forbidden. 30 Not applicable, as cremation is prohibited. The body must be treated with respect and buried as soon as possible. Cremation is considered an unclean and forbidden practice. 32

With all these different and conflicting traditions, it's no wonder people feel unsure. Even if you're not religious, the long-standing Christian preference for burial can create a vague feeling that keeping ashes at home is just... not the right thing to do.

The Psychology of Grief

Looking past superstition, the choice to keep pet ashes is deeply psychological. For many, the ashes are a healthy and important part of grieving. For others, they can become a focus for emotional pain.

Psychological Insight: Keeping ashes can be part of "continuing bonds," a modern grief theory suggesting that it's healthy to maintain a connection with the deceased. It reframes the memorial from a sign of being "stuck" to a comforting link to a loved one.

The main reason people keep ashes is for a tangible connection. When a pet is gone, that empty space is huge, and an urn provides a physical presence you can see and touch. 37 This can be a huge comfort, making the separation feel less sharp.

For many owners, bringing the ashes home is the last act of care they can provide, and it brings a sense of closure. 38 People often create small memorials with the urn, photos, and a favorite toy. 38 This is a therapeutic way to process the loss, not a morbid obsession. 41

A person's hand gently touching a pet urn on a shelf, showing a moment of quiet reflection.

But there can be a downside. For some, the urn becomes a constant, painful reminder of the loss, making it harder to move on. 3 Instead of a happy memory, the urn feels like an anchor to sadness.

In these cases, the "bad luck" people feel is really their own internal pain being blamed on an object. 44 The "negative energy" isn't coming from the ashes, but from the owner's unprocessed grief. This is especially true when society doesn't take pet loss seriously, leaving the owner to grieve alone. 10

A Modern Way to Remember

Despite the anxieties, the main view today is that keeping pet ashes is a normal, healthy act of love. This is a mainstream practice for millions of pet owners, supported by a huge, multi-billion-dollar industry. 37

The business of pet memorials has helped make keeping ashes at home normal. The global pet funeral market was worth around $1.7 to $1.95 billion in 2023-2024 and is expected to more than double by the early 2030s. 11, 50 This growth is driven by people treating their pets like family and wanting to give them a proper send-off. 11

This market offers tons of products designed to make a pet's remains a beautiful part of your home. The basic box from the vet has been replaced by decorative urns made of wood, ceramic, or stone that match your decor. 39 By turning the ashes into a treasured keepsake inside a piece of art, the industry has totally changed their meaning.

It's not just urns. You can get cremation jewelry, like necklaces that hold a tiny bit of ash, so you can keep your pet close. 39 You can even have ashes turned into glass art, memorial diamonds, or pressed into a vinyl record with your pet's barks or purrs. 39 These popular products fight the "bad luck" idea, reframing the ashes from a creepy object into a cherished item that helps you grieve.

A collection of modern pet memorial items, including a glass art piece with ashes, a pendant, and a decorative urn.

So... Is It Bad Luck?

So, what's the verdict? There's no real, ancient superstition saying pet ashes bring bad luck. It’s a modern fear, patched together from a few different sources as keeping pet memorials at home has become more common.

The worry comes from a few places. First, spiritual practices like Feng Shui warn against keeping objects tied to death ( Yin ) in a living space ( Yang ). 23 Second, some paranormal beliefs suggest ashes can "anchor" a spirit to our world. 21 And finally, we're basically applying our old human anxieties about death and proper burials to our pets, who we now see as family. 16

In the end, whether the ashes feel like "bad luck" or "negative energy" is totally up to you. There's no scientific proof that ashes give off bad vibes. 10 The feeling usually comes from your personal spiritual beliefs or your own grief. 10 If you follow Feng Shui, you might feel an energy imbalance, if you feel guilty about your pet's death, you might blame those feelings on the urn.

For most people, keeping their pet's ashes is a comforting, healthy, and loving act of remembrance. 15 The only question that matters is this: What gives you peace? If having the urn nearby makes you feel connected and comforted, then it's a good thing.

If it makes you anxious for any reason, then scattering or burying them is an equally beautiful choice. 39 The goal is to honor your friend in a way that helps you heal.

Works cited

  1. Receiving pet's ashes.. how to deal. - Forum - Rainbow Bridge, https://forums.rainbowsbridge.com/post/receiving-pets-ashes-how-to-deal-7315638
  2. Did anyone feel it was worth it to keep the ashes? : r/Petloss - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/Petloss/comments/svajhy/did_anyone_feel_it_was_worth_it_to_keep_the_ashes/
  3. pawsintograce.com, https://pawsintograce.com/is-it-bad-keep-pet-ashes-home/#:~:text=There's%20no%20proven%20bad%20omen,preventing%20you%20from%20moving%20on.
  4. Is It Bad to Keep Pet Ashes at Home? - Paws Into Grace, https://pawsintograce.com/is-it-bad-keep-pet-ashes-home/
  5. Is It Bad To Keep A Pet's Ashes At Home? - Chieu Minh, https://chieuminh.com/en/is-it-bad-to-keep-a-pets-ashes-at-home/
  6. If I spread my dogs ashes when he passed will I get to see him in the ..., https://www.reddit.com/r/Petloss/comments/1737c9n/if_i_spread_my_dogs_ashes_when_he_passed_will_i/
  7. Is It Bad Luck To Keep Ashes In The House? - Mornington Green Legacy Gardens, https://morningtongreen.com.au/is-it-bad-luck-to-keep-ashes-in-the-house/
  8. Is keeping your deceased pet's fur the same as keeping their ashes? Is it also bad Feng Shui to keep it? : r/FengShui - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/FengShui/comments/17uoev9/is_keeping_your_deceased_pets_fur_the_same_as/
  9. Ashes kept in the house is a ghost more likely to be present? | Halloween, https://scattering-ashes.co.uk/general/ashes-kept-in-the-house-is-a-ghost-more-likely-to-be-present/
  10. Is It Bad Luck to Keep Pet Ashes at Home? Exploring Grief & Memorials - Twinkle Land, https://twinkleland.co/blogs/news/is-it-bad-luck-to-keep-pet-ashes-at-home-revealing-the-truth-few-people-tell-you
  11. Pet Funeral Services Market Share – Trends Report, 2024 – 2032, https://www.gminsights.com/industry-analysis/pet-funeral-services-market
  12. Remembering With Love: The Rise Of Pet Cremation And Evolving Attitudes Toward Animal Companions - UniqueUrn, https://www.uniqueurn.com/rise-of-meaningful-pet-cremation-trend/
  13. THE DEAD BODY Myths, Rites and Superstitions* - Revista Lusófona de Estudos Culturais, https://rlec.pt/index.php/rlec/article/download/1722/1705/1853
  14. Pet Memorials Market: Future Outlook and Trends 2035 - WiseGuy Reports, https://www.wiseguyreports.com/reports/pet-memorials-market
  15. Pet Funeral Services Market Size, Share & 2030 Growth Trends Report - Mordor Intelligence, https://www.mordorintelligence.com/industry-reports/pet-funeral-services-market
  16. 7 Ways the Living Tried to Keep the Dead in Their Graves | HISTORY, https://www.history.com/articles/graves-skeletons-burials-superstitions
  17. Superstitions & Storage: Keeping Ashes at Home | CV Gower Funeral Directors Winscombe North Somerset, https://www.cvgower.co.uk/superstitions-storage-keeping-ashes-at-home/
  18. Is it Bad Luck to have Ashes in the House?, https://scattering-ashes.co.uk/different-cultures/is-it-bad-luck-to-have-ashes-in-the-house/
  19. Any superstitions surrounding body treatment, affecting the afterlife?? : r/mythology - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/mythology/comments/17kcvv8/any_superstitions_surrounding_body_treatment/
  20. 7 Unique Burial Rituals Across the World | Britannica, https://www.britannica.com/list/7-unique-burial-rituals-across-the-world
  21. Do Cremation Ashes Invite Spirits to Stay Around Home? - Trupoint Memorials, https://trupointmemorials.com/blogs/news/do-cremation-ashes-invite-spirits-to-stay-around-home
  22. Can Cremated Remains Attract Ghosts? - Direct Cremate, https://www.directcremate.com/can-cremated-remains-attract-ghosts/
  23. Feng Shui Manhattan New York Long Island Consultant Laura ..., https://fengshuimanhattan.com/blog/2020/12/19/feng-shui-tips-on-where-to-place-cremated-ashes
  24. Is it Bad Feng Shui to Keep Ashes in Your Home? - Affordable Urns, https://affordableurns.com.au/pages/bad-feng-shui-ashes-home
  25. Ashes and Ancestry - Aelita Leto, https://aelitaleto.com/ashes-and-ancestry/
  26. Is There Energy in Cremated Ashes? Science, Spirituality & Symbolism - Forever Urns, https://forever-urns.co.nz/pages/energy-in-cremated-ashes
  27. The best place to store ashes - Clear Space Living, https://www.clearspaceliving.com/blog/the-best-place-to-store-ashes/
  28. Do Cremation Ashes Have Energy? - In The Light Urns, https://inthelighturns.com/blog/is-there-energy-in-cremation-ashes
  29. what-is-the-spiritual-perspective-on-scattering-the-ashes-from-cremation-urn - Salagram.Net, https://www.salagram.net/what-is-the-spiritual-perspective-on-scattering-the-ashes-from-cremation-urn.html
  30. What Religions Don't Believe in Cremation? - Better Place Forests, https://www.betterplaceforests.com/blog/what-religions-believe-in-cremation/
  31. Religious Views on Cremation | Robinson Funeral Home, https://robinsonfuneralhomes.com/religious-views-on-cremation/
  32. Religious Perspectives On Cremation | National Cremation, https://www.nationalcremation.com/cremation-information/religious-views-on-cremation
  33. What to do with cremation ashes - The Catholic Times, https://catholictimescolumbus.org/news/father-paul-keller-op-s-t-d/what-to-do-with-cremation-ashes
  34. How do different religions handle cremated ashes? - Trupoint Memorials Community, https://trupointmemorials.com/a/s/community/cremation/how-do-different-religions-handle-cremated-ashes
  35. 13 Different Religious Perspectives on Cremation | Everplans, https://www.everplans.com/articles/13-different-religious-perspectives-on-cremation
  36. 8 Religions and Their Views on Cremation | Neptune Society, https://neptunesociety.com/resources/cremation-planning/8-religions-and-their-views-on-cremation
  37. Is it bad to keep a pet's ashes at home? - Trupoint Memorials Community, https://trupointmemorials.com/a/s/community/pets/is-it-bad-to-keep-a-pet-s-ashes-at-home
  38. Is It Good to Keep Your Dog's Ashes? - Animal Family Pet Preservation, https://animalfamilypet.com/2024/08/is-it-good-to-keep-your-dogs-ashes/
  39. Keeping Pet Ashes at Home After Pet Cremation - OneWorld Memorials, https://www.oneworldmemorials.com/blogs/news/keeping-pet-ashes-at-home-after-pet-cremation
  40. Is it weird to keep my dog's ashes in the living room? - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/dogs/comments/11tdjiz/is_it_weird_to_keep_my_dogs_ashes_in_the_living/
  41. How do you handle ashes? : r/Petloss - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/Petloss/comments/1diqcz4/how_do_you_handle_ashes/
  42. I sleep with my dogs ashes (in his urn/box) beside me. He slept on a pillow beside me for 12 and a half years. I can't handle him not being there anymore. Is this normal? : r/Petloss - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/Petloss/comments/1eurxd1/i_sleep_with_my_dogs_ashes_in_his_urnbox_beside/
  43. does anyone else talk to their pets ashes like how you normally would have when they were alive : r/Petloss - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/Petloss/comments/1fiypa4/does_anyone_else_talk_to_their_pets_ashes_like/
  44. What Your Choice About Your Pet's Cremation Says About You, https://helpinghandspethospice.com/what-your-choice-about-your-pets-cremation-says-about-you-2/
  45. Seeing Ghosts of Their Dogs Can Help Grieving Pet Parents, New Study Says - Kinship, https://www.kinship.com/dog-lifestyle/paranormal-experiences-comfort-pet-parents-news
  46. 5 Things to do with Your Pet's Ashes - Family Pet Cremations, https://www.familypetcremations.net/5-things-to-do-with-your-pets-ashes
  47. Pet Funeral Services Market Size, Share & Forecast, https://www.verifiedmarketresearch.com/product/pet-funeral-services-market/
  48. Pet Funeral Services Market Size, Share and Growth Report - Precision Business Insights, https://www.precisionbusinessinsights.com/market-reports/pet-funeral-services-market
  49. Pet Funeral Services Market Size To Reach $3.75Bn By 2030 - Grand View Research, https://www.grandviewresearch.com/press-release/global-pet-funeral-services-market
  50. Pet Memorials Market Size - Forecast Till 2033 - Business Research Insights, https://www.businessresearchinsights.com/market-reports/pet-memorials-market-109848
  51. Pet Funeral Services Market Size And Share Report, 2030, https://www.grandviewresearch.com/industry-analysis/pet-funeral-services-market-report
  52. 2024 Pet Memorialisation Trends - Petributes, https://www.petributes.co.uk/blog/2024-pet-memorialisation-trends/
  53. How Americans Memorialize Their Dogs | Psychology Today, https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/canine-corner/202103/how-americans-memorialize-their-dogs
  54. Can You Keep Cremated Remains at Home?, https://www.williamsfh.com/can-you-keep-cremated-remains-at-home